一審死刑判決その後
ここでは、一審で言い渡された死刑判決が、控訴審や最終段階ではどのように変化したかを見てみる。2010年末
１：控訴審判決
下の表見出しのうち、「破棄死刑」は、一審の死刑判決を破棄して、改めて死刑を言い渡した場合。また、「その他」は、控訴取り下げ・非上訴・死亡による公訴棄却のケースである。
|
一審判決年度別 |
| 年 |
総数 |
控訴
棄却 |
破棄
差戻 |
破棄
無罪 |
破棄
有期 |
破棄
無期 |
破棄
死刑 |
未決 |
その他 |
| 1956 |
２４ |
１５ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
| 1957 |
３５ |
１９ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１１ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
| 1958 |
２５ |
１６ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
| 1959 |
２８ |
２４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1960 |
１２ |
７ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
| 1961 |
２９ |
１８ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
８ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
| 1962 |
１２ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1963 |
１２ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
１ |
０ |
３ |
| 1964 |
１２ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1965 |
１６ |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1966 |
１４ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１ |
０ |
３ |
| 1967 |
７ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1968 |
１５ |
１２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
| 1969 |
９ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
１ |
０ |
３ |
| 1970 |
９ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1971 |
４ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1972 |
３ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1973 |
４ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1974 |
６ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1975 |
５ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1976 |
４ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1977 |
９ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1978 |
６ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1979 |
７ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1980 |
９ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1981 |
２ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1982 |
１１ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1983 |
５ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1984 |
６ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1985 |
９ |
８ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1986 |
５ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1987 |
６ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
| 1988 |
１０ |
７ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1989 |
２ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1990 |
２ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1991 |
３ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1992 |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1993 |
４ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1994 |
８ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1995 |
１１ |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1996 |
１ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1997 |
３ |
１ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1998 |
７ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 1999 |
８ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
１ |
| 2000 |
１４ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
| 2001 |
１０ |
８ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
１ |
| 2002 |
１８ |
１５ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
| 2003 |
１３ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 2004 |
１４ |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
| 2005 |
１３ |
１１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
| 2006 |
１３ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
| 2007 |
１４ |
１１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
| 2008 |
５ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
| 2009 |
９ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
２ |
| 2010 |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
０ |
２：確定判決
下の表見出しのうち、「その他」は、死亡による公訴棄却のケースである。
また、９７年に一審判決を受けたのは３人だが、うち２名は二審で差し戻されているので、計上しなかった。
|
一審判決年度別 |
| 年 |
総数 |
無罪 |
有期 |
無期 |
死刑 |
未決 |
その他 |
| 1956 |
２４ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
１８ |
０ |
１ |
| 1957 |
３５ |
０ |
１ |
１１ |
２３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1958 |
２５ |
０ |
１ |
６ |
１８ |
０ |
０ |
| 1959 |
２８ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
２５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1960 |
１２ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
| 1961 |
２９ |
０ |
０ |
８ |
１９ |
０ |
２ |
| 1962 |
１２ |
０ |
２ |
４ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
| 1963 |
１２ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
８ |
０ |
２ |
| 1964 |
１２ |
０ |
０ |
６ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
| 1965 |
１６ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
１１ |
０ |
０ |
| 1966 |
１４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1967 |
７ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1968 |
１５ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１４ |
０ |
０ |
| 1969 |
９ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
７ |
０ |
０ |
| 1970 |
９ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1971 |
４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1972 |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1973 |
４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1974 |
６ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
| 1975 |
５ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
| 1976 |
４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1977 |
９ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1978 |
６ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1979 |
７ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1980 |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
８ |
０ |
１ |
| 1981 |
２ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
０ |
| 1982 |
１１ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
| 1983 |
５ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
３ |
０ |
０ |
| 1984 |
６ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1985 |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
９ |
０ |
０ |
| 1986 |
５ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
０ |
０ |
| 1987 |
６ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
| 1988 |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
７ |
０ |
０ |
| 1989 |
２ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
| 1990 |
２ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
| 1991 |
３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
０ |
１ |
| 1992 |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
| 1993 |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
０ |
０ |
| 1994 |
８ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
６ |
０ |
０ |
| 1995 |
１１ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
| 1996 |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
| 1997 |
１ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
０ |
０ |
| 1998 |
７ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
７ |
０ |
０ |
| 1999 |
８ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
０ |
３ |
| 2000 |
１４ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
１１ |
０ |
２ |
| 2001 |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１０ |
０ |
０ |
| 2002 |
１８ |
０ |
０ |
３ |
１４ |
１ |
０ |
| 2003 |
１３ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
８ |
２ |
１ |
| 2004 |
１４ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
１２ |
０ |
０ |
| 2005 |
１３ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
８ |
３ |
１ |
| 2006 |
１３ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
８ |
５ |
１ |
| 2007 |
１４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
５ |
９ |
０ |
| 2008 |
５ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
１ |
３ |
１ |
| 2009 |
９ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
２ |
７ |
０ |
| 2010 |
４ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
０ |
４ |
０ |
|
